I enjoy all kinds of cheese. I love queso fresco and queso oxaca. But under no circumstances would I advocate, let alone eat, bathtub cheese.
Topolobampo
A few weeks ago my wife took me to Topolobampo with friends for my 35th birthday. It was actually a birthday surprise, which was pretty damn cool! I’m not easy to surprise… Topolobampo is Rick Bayless’ fine dining Mexican restaurant in Chicago, the “upscale sister” to the Frontera Grill. The name comes from a port in Mexico that was also once home to a utopian colony in the late 1800s.
The atmosphere is really fantastic. It’s adjacent to Frontera, but much darker and more sedate. It’s quieter, which lends itself to good dinner conversation. Our server, Oliver, was friendly without being pushy, had excellent recommendations and was very attentive without being obnoxious. Oh, and Bayless himself was dining a few tables over, which is always a good sign.
Now, the food! My friend Ken had the Pato al Pasilla con Higos, which was a pan-roasted duck breast in a sauce made from pasilla chiles and figs, with a bacon and potento torda, green beans, and a fig-jicama salsa. It looked very delicious. His girlfriend Kelly had the Borrego en Mole Coloradito, which I was able to sample as well as part of the chef’s menu.
Since it was my birthday, my wife and I splurged and went with the degustation menu. I went all out, and got the wine pairings as well–and I’m glad I did!
The first course was Sopes de Papa con Mantarraya, which were these little potato-masa “boats” that were filled with a tomato braised skatewing. It was topped with some roasted tomatoes, capers and pickled jalapeno salad with queso fresco. They were delicious. The skatewing was perfect, and the potato-masa boats gave a nice texture contrast. This course was paired with a 2004 Nora Da Neve Albarino, a Spanish wine that was *perfect* with this course. Absolutely perfect. By itself, I think the wine was decent, but not something I’d normally drink, but it just matched the flavors of the tomato and and skatewing to perfection.
Next was Sopa Azteca de Hongos Silvestres, which as a wild mushroom broth, flavored with pasilla chiles, tomatos and epazote, with crispy torillas, mushrooms, and cheese. I wasn’t as impressed with this dish–it was server lukewarm, and I just prefer my soup hot. The taste of the broth was nice, and the cheese was fantastic. But overall, I was a little disappointed with the dish. It was paired with a 2004 Andrew Murray Vinyards “Enchante” from California, which was a nice pairing, but after the perfection of the first dish, my expectations were built up to expect more.
Fortunately, the next dish, Arroz a la Tumbada, was back on top. This was a Mexican “paella” which had mahimahi, shrimp, scallops, Dungeness crab and baby octopus, served over white rice with a roasted tomato-jalapeño salsa. Oh. Man. The seafood was perfectly cooked. I mean, perfect. The scallops were done to perfection, and all of the dishes components came together perfectly as one–not a collection of different ingredients. It was paired with a 2002 Joan D’Anguera “Finca L’Agrata” from Spain, which at first seemed an odd pairing–it’s a red, syrah/cab blend(?), a bright berry taste and a hint of pepper, not unlike a Zinfandel. It was quite tasty on it’s own, and it actually worked as a pairing, so I was pretty pleased.
The final dish was Borrego en Mole Coloradito, which was the lamb dish that Kelly had. The lamb was done to perfection, delicate and succulent. It was served in an ancho chile mole, with wild mushroom/chocolate tamales and spinach. The lamb itself was my favorite dish of the night. I’d never had lamb with a mole, but it was divine. The mole was one of the best I’ve ever had, and it was just fantastic with the lamb. The spinach was great (it be hard to mess up spinach!) but I really could have lived without the tamales. They didn’t look particularly appetizing, as they had a dark brown color and a shape that just–well, let’s say if you ran across them at the dog park… At first, I thought they were interesting, but after a bite or two, the mushroom and chocolate were just not working together well. Overall they were the biggest disappointment of the night. This dish was paired with a 2004 Betts & Scholl Grenache, from Australia, which wasn’t the best pairing of the night, but was solid.
Finally, we ended with a sample of desserts: a chocolate and banana tart with peanut frangipan, prickly pear ice cream with chocolate sauce, and a passionfruit panna cotta. The tart was good, but somewhat typical, and the prickly pear ice cream was pretty good. I’d never had prickly pear ice cream before but I would again. Really, though, it was the passionfruit panna cotta that really stood out, it was incredible. It was a great balance of sweet and tart, and was garnished with a thin slice of dried passionfruit that just put it over the top. I would have gladly traded the other two desserts for more of the passionfruit! The dessert was paired with a 2005 Hirschbach & Sohne “Binger St. Rochuskapelle”, an Eiswein from Germany. I may love German beer, but I really don’t care for German wine. If you like eiswein, it would probably be a good pairing, but I find it cloying.
Overall, I thought Topolobampo was really a fantastic dining experience. The atmosphere was exactly what I want in a fine dining restaurant: subtle and elegant. The staff were on their game and the service was excellent. And the food was out of this world. Yes, there were some “misses” on the degustation menu, but I think that’s to be expected. It means the Chef is taking some risks, and on some dishes, it really pays off, even if occasionally it doesn’t.
There was also a final surprise (my wife really went all out this year, did I mention how much I love her?!!) which was a copy of Mexico: One Plate at a Time that she had gotten Chef Bayless to personalize for me. A very cool 35th birthday, indeed.
So, if you’re looking for a great fine dining experience in Chicago with a great ethnic twist, I think Topolobampo is an excellent choice. I will definitely be returning!
Petit Livarot de la Perelle
This year, for my birthday, my friend Amy gave the gift of cheese! The first cheese I got to sample was Livarot is a washed rind cheese that hails from Normandy. It’s made from cow’s milk, and is shipped in a wood box, wrapped with strips of paper (or bullrush leaves) in a five-band pattern, which gives rise to the knickname The Colonel. The particular cheese I had was a Petit Livarot de la Perelle.
The cheese has an orange-reddish rind, which results from the washing, which promotes the bacterim Brevibacterium linens, the rind is slightly sticky, and pungent. And when I say pungent, I mean, my wife wouldn’t let me keep it in the fridge more than a day pungent!
If you can get past the smell–and I highly recommend that you do! You will find a cheese that is very, very delicious and not nearly as strong as the smell would indicate. The interior ranges from slightly runny to more firm, with a few small holes and a light, straw yellow color.
The taste is milder, with a very slight gaminess–mostly a hold-over from the rind smell. Getting away from the area closer to the rind, it is a very pleasant, mild taste with a little bit of spice and a slight hint of pepper. It’s a complex cheese that doesn’t really need any accompaniment, I just enjoyed it straight up, by itself.
The washed rind cheeses aren’t for everyone, it takes a lot of people a while to get past the pungent smell. But I invite you to be adventurous and give it a try, you might be surprised that something that smells so strong could be so mild and delicious!
Bonne Bouche
Another birthday cheese from Amy was Bonne Bouche (which means “good mouthful” or “delicious morsel”) which is a pasteurized goat’s milk cheese from the Vermont Butter and Cheese Company.
Bonne Bouche is an American Cheese Society winner for aged goat cheese and one taste and it’s not hard to see why! It’s an ash-ripened cheese, with a mottled green-grey rind and a very soft, creamy texture–but not runny. You can eat Bonne Bouche as a young cheese or as an aged cheese, depending on your preference.
The taste is very characteristic of a great goat cheese–nice and creamy, wuth hints of citrus and a very lemony aftertaste. For a goat cheese lover like me, this was a fantastic hit. If you’ve enjoyed any of the other goat cheeses that I’ve recommended (such as Humboldt Fog) you should definitely give Bonne Bouche a try!
Dubliner
A friend of mine recently said, “What cheese should I buy if I’m not at la fromagerie? What if I’m just at [gigantor supermarket] and want some normal cheese to eat? What should I buy then?”
Well, without digressing into what exactly a “normal” cheese is supposed to be, or why it’s so worth the extra trip to a well-stocked cheese monger, I thought, “okay… what would I buy?”
I can tell you what I would not buy. I would not buy a cheese that was labeled “cheese product” or “cheese food”. Nor would I buy a “brie” that comes in a plastic container. Why not just spread paste on your baguette?
But there are some decent mass-market cheeses that are pretty tasty and easy to find in many major chain groceries. Today I give you one such cheese: Dubliner.
Dubliner is marketed under the Kerrygold brand but is actually made by a large dairy/food ingredients manufacturer in Cork called Carbery. Their website lists several varieties of Dubliner, but I’ve only encountered the “Vintage” and the “White”. Today, I’ll be tasting the “White” as it seems to be the most commonly available.
Dubliner is an aged cheese, similar to a cheddar. (The Kerrygold website calls it “not unlike a cheddar…”) Well, if you like aged cheddar, you will probably like Dubliner. It’s not a sharp as some aged cheddars I’ve had, but it is pleasantly sharp and nutty. It has a nice, tight curd and is dry–slightly flakey, but melts nicely in your mouth.
Those Carbery folks do have a good sense of “mouthfeel”. Even the white, which I gather is not aged as long as the “vintage” has a few calcium lactate crystals, which I just love encountering in an aged cheese.
Overall, Dubliner is a very nice mass-market cheese and a great snack cheese. This recipe for Guinness Dubliner cheese soup also sounds pretty good. So if you are in the local mega-mart and you want to grab some cheese without making a special trip to a cheese shop, I’d say Dubliner isn’t a bad way to go at all!
Munster
Munster is a washed rind, raw cow’s milk cheese, which hails from the Alsace region in France. Real Munster enjoys AOC (Appellation d’Origine Controlee) protection, which means if you don’t see “AOC” on the label, it’s not the real deal.
Munster should also not be confused with Muenster, which is an American cheese, and really bears no resemblance to actual Munster.
Real Munster is not a cheese for the weak of nose or those who don’t enjoy a strong cheese. I bought a fresh piece, cut right before my eyes from a whole round. My wife thought it smelled like old sweat socks and made me put it in it’s own grocery bag, least it contaminate everything. It has a beautiful, red rind and a straw colored, semi-soft interior, which has some small air bubbles in it.
Like many washed rind cheeses, the flavor of Munster is on par with the smell. If you are not a strong cheese fan, then you may want to proceed with caution. The cheese has a strong barnyard taste, with a hint of vegetation and slight tangy/astringent aftertaste. Because it’s a washed rind cheese, it’s also slightly salty–I think it would go pretty well with beer.
If you are a strong cheese lover, you owe it to yourself to taste a real Munster, it’s delicious. However, if you don’t have the nose or palette for a strong cheese, start with some milder raw milk offerings before you jump in with this one.
Morbier
Happy New Year!
What better way to ring in the New Year, than with some cheese! Today, I came across some Morbier, and it’s been a while since I’ve done a cow’s milk cheese, so I thought, “Why not?!”
Morbier is a French cheese, made from raw (unpasteurized) cow’s milk. It has a pungent aroma, but a milder taste that it’s odor might suggest. Morbier also enjoys AOC (Appellation d’origine contrôlée) protection, which means if you see Morbier on-sale with a label that says “AOC” and”au lait cru” you are getting the real deal.
Morbier started off as a left-over cheese that cheesemakers basically made for themselves. Cheesemakers who were making Comté (another wonderful cheese–but that’s another review) would save the left-over curd and make a pale straw colored, semi-soft cheese for their own personal enjoyment. Because Morbier was made from leftovers, they would cover the morning curds in ash to prevent them from forming a rind, and then add the afternoon milk on top. The result was a cheese with two halves and a distinctive line of ash in the middle.
I’ve seen various sites today that say this morning/afternoon tradition is carried out, and others that say the ash is now ornamental. The later seems more likely to me, and I couldn’t taste the difference between the two halves on this round.
If you’re like many people, the idea of a stinky cheese isn’t your thing. I will caution that Morbier does have a distinct, strong odor. To me, it smells very earthy and farm-like. You can definitely smell “yeast” as well. However, I think the flavor is much more mild than the smell.
Texture wise, it’s a softer cheese, but not runny. It’s kind of squishy, in a good way. It melts in your mouth, with caramel notes and a slight nuttiness, and a distinctive “hay” or “straw” taste. It really does taste like a cheese you would be served at a farmhouse after coming in for lunch from the field.
If you see this one at your local cheese shop or grocery, I recommend picking it up as a good sampling of a raw cow milk that comes on a little strong, but lands you softly in the hay.
Saint Felix
This weekend was an extraordinarily good cheese weekend. I wandered into my local cheese shop, Marion Street Cheese Market and asked my cheese monger, “What have you got that you really like?”
Well, he was quite excited to be carrying cheeses by a cheesemaker from Wisconsin, Felix Thalhammer. Apparently, Marion St. is the first shop outside Wisconsin to carry Felix’s aged cheeses. Now that I’ve sampled them, I can see why Eric was so excited!
Felix owns Capri Creamery specializing in artisan goat cheeses. The first cheese I tried and purchased is Saint Felix.
St. Felix is an aged, washed rind goat cheese, which take 2-3 years to prepare. The St. Felix is apparently the first of these cheeses, and let me assure you, it’s fantastic.
The cheese has a good, strong smell, you just know it’s going to be good! It has a nice, firm texture, with a larger crumble, so it has a nice bite to it, but it still feels great in your mouth, maybe even a little “fatter” than most goat’s milk cheese feel. It’s a washed rind cheese, so it’s nice and salty, with a slightly gritty, nutty finish that will remind you slightly of Parmesan.
Since Felix’s cheeses are made by hand by him alone, they’re probably going to be hard to find outside of the Midwest, or even Wisconsin for that matter! But I did notice you can order on his website. You should do yourself a favor and order some. If the St. Felix is any indication of Felix’s talent for cheese, we should have some really stunning cheeses down the road!
Coming soon, Govarti…
Midnight Moon
I have to hand it to the folks at Cyrpress Grove Chevre, they know their goat cheeses!
As you may already know, Cypress makes one of my favorite cheeses, Humboldt Fog so it wasn’t hard to get me to try Midnight Moon, which is an aged goat cheese, very Gouda like in style, taste and appearance.
This one isn’t actually made by Cypress Grove, it’s made for them by a Dutch company (hence the Gouda style, I presume). It’s aged just right, with a few crunchy crystals and a nice, firm texture. It’s got a little bit of that goat tang, but it’s still pretty rich in buttery, caramel goodness. It’s a very, very tasty cheese and makes a delightful snack.
Florette
Yesterday I had a goat’s milk brie style cheese called Florette. It’s a creamy white mold cheese, imagine a texture similar to brie or Camembert, but with it’s own flavor.
Unlike some other cream goat cheeses, that shall remain nameless, Florette is extremely mild, and not marked by a strong goat flavor or even a pronounced tang. Instead, it’s a smooth and deliciously creamy treat, with a very subtle flavor. Anytime you might think you’d be in the mood for Brie, mix things up a bit with Florette and I don’t think you’d be disappointed.